Share this
Mister Wong
Digg
Del.icio.us
Slashdot
Furl
Yahoo
Technorati
Newsvine
Googlize this
Blinklist
Facebook
Wikio
Export PDF
Print
E-mail
Tags
Rally for Canada: The First Refuge for Harper
by C. L. Cook
There is a crisis of democracy unfolding in Canada. Yes, staid, stable, and plainly boring Canada is in the middle of a politcal power struggle that has injected the capital Ottawa and the nation with a substance foreign: Excitement!
by C. L. Cook
There is a crisis of democracy unfolding in Canada. Yes, staid, stable, and plainly boring Canada is in the middle of a politcal power struggle that has injected the capital Ottawa and the nation with a substance foreign: Excitement!
Forget Obamarama; Canada today is buzzing with the hope three successive minority-government rule will be coming to an end. What this potentially means is real change, for the time being, in the way the country is run.
The British parliamentary system allows the occasional quirks of the dissolution of parliament and unseating of government outside the electoral process. That is the usual fate of minority governments, where the party in power has the single party majority, but not the total seat majority in a multi-partied parliament. Stephen Harper's ruling Conservatives are in this unenviable position and now, through Mr. Harper's natural bellicosity and incessant bullying, the opposition parties are driven into each other's arms to bring down the prime minister in the House of Commons and form a coalition government. This barely six weeks after "winning" his second minority "mandate."
Though Canada's tradition has long included third parties, the country has essentially suffered the caprices, venality, and corruption of either the Liberals or Tories by turn since its 1867 confederation. Canadians seem tired of this endless yo-yo-ing and the last federal election returns verify this, if turnout is an accurate indicator. Roughly 43% of those eligible did not cast a ballot. That is the highest disaffection percentage in the nation's history. While Canadians watched the Obama hype building to crescendo in the south, they turned off the Harper v. Dion '08 race.
Though Canada's tradition has long included third parties, the country has essentially suffered the caprices, venality, and corruption of either the Liberals or Tories by turn since its 1867 confederation. Canadians seem tired of this endless yo-yo-ing and the last federal election returns verify this, if turnout is an accurate indicator. Roughly 43% of those eligible did not cast a ballot. That is the highest disaffection percentage in the nation's history. While Canadians watched the Obama hype building to crescendo in the south, they turned off the Harper v. Dion '08 race.
But that may have been premature.
While Obama's rising star seems to have crested, its zenith abruptly stunted by Empire's changeless Realpolitic, his message of hope seeming less a possibility than wishful thinking with each new appointment, the Canadian political scene promises a real change at a time when the nation's policies and political structures so desperately need it.
Stephen Harper came out swinging today, vowing to fight the conspiracy of the opposition Liberal, Bloc Quebecois and New Democratic parties with everything he has. It's easy to catalogue just what "everything" Harper has to work with:
In support of this rally, the prime minister has evoked the twin terrors of every Christian conservative: Socialism and Separatism. Harper, whose animosity toward Quebec is famously available on the internet, is now invoking a Bloc Quebecois bogie man to scare Canadians into the streets in his support. And, in an echo of the defeated John McCain, the north of 49 Republican is lashing out at the "socialist" New Democratic Party coalition member. As he did during the election, Harper has chosen divisive politics with truly ugly undertones in a desperate effort to maintain his "win at all cost" political philosophy.
The conservatives and their allied foes each offer explanations for what has shaken Canada's political scene over the last week. It is no surprise these differ significantly. But, neither party has uttered the real reasons behind the attempted ouster of Stephen Harper's government. Harper has run rough-shod over the country's traditional values, replacing whole cloth the political and social culture with a cheap facsimile of the disastrous late-American variety. He is unapologetic about his nation-changing program, if low-key about its particulars and what they mean for the future of the nation.
In the final analysis, Canada has returned an unprecedented three minority governments. Nearly two-thirds of those voting preferred left of centre policies, yet the most stridently right-wing prime minister in modern history calls Sussex Drive home. Harper's big mistake was to provoke the majority opposition with legislation they could not swallow, (in this case, proposing legislation to end federal matching funds to political parties), again humiliating them; this so soon after their respective election losses. For this hubris Harper will fall, and we can only thank the humility of the Liberal and NDP and Bloc Quebecois leaders who may now must hold their noses to sit together and make Canada back from what remains after Harper's tenure.
i) Legal options: None. The opposition has every legal and democratic right to question the competency of the governing party; and, failing to find confidence in that party, they and the Governor-General are duty-bound to find confidence in the House.
Harper has threatened to prorogue the parliament. This simply means ceasing the political operations of the parliament, thus avoiding introducing any legislation that would provoke a no confidence vote. This would be unprecedented at this stage of any sitting Canadian government. Proroguing is always the last act of a government before an election. Never has this kind of closure been used for this purpose in the history of the nation. Nevertheless, Harper is expected to request of GG, Michaëlle Jean the stoppage to buy time.
ii) Extra-legal options: Harper has friends in high places. Canada's corporate and State-run media coverage reveals an obvious pro-government slant. It runs daily in seamless concert with an expensive election-style advertising campaign launched by the Tories in an effort to sway public opinion, and bring pressure to bear on individual members of parliament and Governor-General Jean.
The Conservative campaign foot-soldiers who featured so large during the recent election too remain well organized, ardent, and are currently spearheading a media/on-line message blitz, and have set up "spontaneous" demonstrations, (some of the images of which appearing uncomfortably reminiscent of the "grassroots Florida" supporters that stopped the vote recount in the 2000 election of George W. Bush). They're planning a national day of protest for Saturday, December 6. Whether accidental, or emblematic of Harper's disdain for feminist, or even female-friendly initiatives and programs, the Tory's 'Rally for Canada' will share public space with remembrance ceremonies for the fourteen women massacred by a mad gunman at Montreal's l'Ecole Polytechnique in 1989; Canada's "Columbine."
In support of this rally, the prime minister has evoked the twin terrors of every Christian conservative: Socialism and Separatism. Harper, whose animosity toward Quebec is famously available on the internet, is now invoking a Bloc Quebecois bogie man to scare Canadians into the streets in his support. And, in an echo of the defeated John McCain, the north of 49 Republican is lashing out at the "socialist" New Democratic Party coalition member. As he did during the election, Harper has chosen divisive politics with truly ugly undertones in a desperate effort to maintain his "win at all cost" political philosophy.
The conservatives and their allied foes each offer explanations for what has shaken Canada's political scene over the last week. It is no surprise these differ significantly. But, neither party has uttered the real reasons behind the attempted ouster of Stephen Harper's government. Harper has run rough-shod over the country's traditional values, replacing whole cloth the political and social culture with a cheap facsimile of the disastrous late-American variety. He is unapologetic about his nation-changing program, if low-key about its particulars and what they mean for the future of the nation.
In the final analysis, Canada has returned an unprecedented three minority governments. Nearly two-thirds of those voting preferred left of centre policies, yet the most stridently right-wing prime minister in modern history calls Sussex Drive home. Harper's big mistake was to provoke the majority opposition with legislation they could not swallow, (in this case, proposing legislation to end federal matching funds to political parties), again humiliating them; this so soon after their respective election losses. For this hubris Harper will fall, and we can only thank the humility of the Liberal and NDP and Bloc Quebecois leaders who may now must hold their noses to sit together and make Canada back from what remains after Harper's tenure.
[Below are a couple of the first salvoes in the PR war in full swing in boring old Canada's political battle to the death.]
You may or may not have visited the website "Rally for Canada" http://www.rallyforcanada.ca/. It is the last desperate act of supporters of the Harper Government. An attempt to stir patriotism against a coalition of political parties holding a majority of seats in the House of Commons and, through such, being enabled by Parliamentary custom to recommend the Prime Minister of Canada to the Governor General.
The action of seeking to launch rallies against legitimate change among a people already shaken by a world wide economic crisis that places them in fear of their livelihoods can be described as nothing else than the last refuge of scoundrels seeking to maintain power at any cost.
Visit the site, there is a dialogue taking place if you have the skills to fully access it.
Joe Hueglin
p.s. Just in as this was written is a supportive document from Stephen Harper's former employers who are, apparently, ignorant of the working of the Parliamentary system.
You may or may not have visited the website "Rally for Canada" http://www.rallyforcanada.ca/. It is the last desperate act of supporters of the Harper Government. An attempt to stir patriotism against a coalition of political parties holding a majority of seats in the House of Commons and, through such, being enabled by Parliamentary custom to recommend the Prime Minister of Canada to the Governor General.
The action of seeking to launch rallies against legitimate change among a people already shaken by a world wide economic crisis that places them in fear of their livelihoods can be described as nothing else than the last refuge of scoundrels seeking to maintain power at any cost.
Visit the site, there is a dialogue taking place if you have the skills to fully access it.
Joe Hueglin
p.s. Just in as this was written is a supportive document from Stephen Harper's former employers who are, apparently, ignorant of the working of the Parliamentary system.
From: ncc@nationalcitizens.ca (The National Citizens Coalition)
Subject: An Open Letter to the Citizens of Canada
An Open Letter to the Citizens of Canada Use Your Voice. Stand Up For Democracy
This letter is an appeal to all Canadian citizens to share your concerns and fight for democracy.
In the recent federal election, Canadians voted for a minority government. You did not vote for an opposition coalition that has given veto power to a party determined to tear apart this country.
This is an unprecedented power grab, and we believe its wrong.
Voting Matters!
The confidence of the people is far more important than the confidence of Parliament.
Contact the Governor General today and let her know it is her responsibility to protect democracy and ensure the citizens of Canada that their voice does matter.
This coalition government is undemocratic and unaccountable - Don't let them take away your voice!
Contact Michelle Jean today and demand that this decision be put in the hands of the Canadian electorate.
The above text is an example of an ad we will be running in the National Post on Friday, December 5, 2008. With you support we can continue to run similar ads in publications across the country.Click here to donate to our campaign to Stand Up for Democracy. Your support is needed now more than ever.
E-mail us at ncc@nationalcitizens.ca to add your voice and provide
feedback on our Open Letter.
Set as favorite
Bookmark
Email This
Comments (10)
Subscribe to this comment's feed
written by G Bennett, December 02, 2008
Taking Taxpayer money back from the parties also applies to the Conservatives , friendly reminder! I would like to hear some examples how Stephen Harper has changed our Traditional values or even how he has made us more American? Was he not the first to declare Quebec as a nation understanding there need for recognition. Ask Judges about the new crime laws I have, " he is going in the right direction" Ask the Military how he has been doing to meet their needs in this ever changing world. Ask my Daughter about new assistance she receives with my new Grandbaby thanks to Mr Harper. Still waiting to see the so SECRET AGENDA he has.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +2
written by Donna, December 02, 2008
we have the very best country in the world, and then some power hungry guys want to destroy this nation. Prime Minister Stephen Harper is rare person, to put up with such abuse that has been thrown at him, and he has worked so hard for Canada, and done an awesome job. We are proud to be Canadians, but if these guys get in, just because they are so jeolous they lost the election, and hate the west so much, we are in serious trouble. Please Stephen Harper fight for our country and we will pray.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +3
written by Yorki, December 03, 2008
Joe, do you suppose you could write a non partisan article? Please don't write your blatantly biased drivel and cry foul at the Conservatives popularity with the press in the same breath.
You are, by existence, a self contradiction. I did not vote for three parties to govern my country, nor will I recognise such a government.
Put your pen down and perhaps take up truck driving or septic tank cleaning.
You are, by existence, a self contradiction. I did not vote for three parties to govern my country, nor will I recognise such a government.
Put your pen down and perhaps take up truck driving or septic tank cleaning.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: -1
written by Jeremy, December 03, 2008
I have little faith in those people who choose to ignore how Canada's Parliamentary democracy works. I do have faith in the Pacific Free Press for publishing this article.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +3
..., Lowly rated comment [Show]
Contacting the Governor-General, Lowly rated comment [Show]
written by G Reid - Kamloops BC, December 04, 2008
Just 6 weeks ago I voted in the Federal election. Regardless of who won the election I was willing to accept the newly elected Gov't. We had a declared winner, the Conservative party took office under "very cloudy economical" conditions. The Gov't is looking both ways before it crosses the tough economical cross-road. Is this such a bad thing?? Would it not be prudent for the Gov't to take their time and evaluate the current economical problems. They have stated that the new budget will be released in January'09. I think it would be foolish for the Gov't not to take a moment and evaluate where our economy is and how can we fix-it. I am not willing to accept a coalition Gov't, a back-room deal that has been made with the (3) devil's, neither the NDP, the Liberals or the Bloc won this election on their own. Now they are willing to jump into bed with each other, just to have the chance to push Canada into debt to the sum of $30-billion . But as Mr Dion has stated "we have a plan to run the country for the next 30 months", yet no one is willing to come public with the details. Should we just give the Coalition Gov't the signed cheque-book and hope they do what is right?? I don't think so!!
The Liberal party just had the worst showing for an election in their history, you must ask yourself why??? Mr Dion is why, no one trust's him, so now we are going to hand the entire country over to him?? He can't lead the Liberal party, so why does he think he can lead our Country??
The Liberal party just had the worst showing for an election in their history, you must ask yourself why??? Mr Dion is why, no one trust's him, so now we are going to hand the entire country over to him?? He can't lead the Liberal party, so why does he think he can lead our Country??
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +1
written by misha, December 05, 2008
Nothing wrong with making the Coalition legal. Harper and his "USA right-wing Republican" roots poses a very destructive political agenda for Canada. 63% of Canadians voted for center-left parties in last election, so I have no problem seeing real change . It could be a bit messy, but losing Harper is totally worth it.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
written by Ann Daniels - Victoria, BC, December 05, 2008
I couldn't agree more! Well said! I will be rallying at the City Hall at noon on the 6th to prove my rejection of the Coalition. I've never been a Conservative voter, but I totally reject the current Liberal & NDP platforms which include, amongst other outrages, the legalization of recreational drug-use. By default, they leave me no choice but to vote Conservative, which I did at the last election, and I'm damned angry to think that these people have the gaul to believe that they can ignore my vote! If you live in Victoria, and suffer the disgust of tripping over drugged-up wasters daily, you'll know why it's Conservative or nothing until we get a more Centralist party on offer! See you at City Hall!
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
written by Barb, December 07, 2008
There are too many people freaking out for no reason about this Coalition, if you voted Conservative of course you didn't like any of the other alternatives.
Did you know this most recent election had the lowest voter turn out in history. Did you ever stop to think that a main cause of this could be apathy towards our currant political system? Did you know that 170,000 LESS people voted conservative than in the last election despite the low turn out and they somehow still got more seats? Democracy isn't on Harper's list. He is bringing Canada closer to fascism. Maybe people should be paying more attention to their MP's and vote for that person instead of a "party".
Honestly what is so wrong with Dion anyways, he cares more about our environment and sustaining our planet! That makes him 100% better than lining our pockets with cash to spend on crap we don't need that is killing our planet because of tax breaks that I don't need and the oil companies pockets, who fund the Conservatives don't need either!
Take a look at what you people are saying and learn about politics before you start ranting about stuff you don't even know. Maybe the world would be a little bit happier if we stopped thinking only of ourselves all the time, and stopped being so obsessed with money.
At least the Coalition has ideas already tabled to help our economy that aren't geared at harming anyone except greedy corporations (oh yeah instead of giving them huge tax breaks....which is all Harper does).
Did you know this most recent election had the lowest voter turn out in history. Did you ever stop to think that a main cause of this could be apathy towards our currant political system? Did you know that 170,000 LESS people voted conservative than in the last election despite the low turn out and they somehow still got more seats? Democracy isn't on Harper's list. He is bringing Canada closer to fascism. Maybe people should be paying more attention to their MP's and vote for that person instead of a "party".
Honestly what is so wrong with Dion anyways, he cares more about our environment and sustaining our planet! That makes him 100% better than lining our pockets with cash to spend on crap we don't need that is killing our planet because of tax breaks that I don't need and the oil companies pockets, who fund the Conservatives don't need either!
Take a look at what you people are saying and learn about politics before you start ranting about stuff you don't even know. Maybe the world would be a little bit happier if we stopped thinking only of ourselves all the time, and stopped being so obsessed with money.
At least the Coalition has ideas already tabled to help our economy that aren't geared at harming anyone except greedy corporations (oh yeah instead of giving them huge tax breaks....which is all Harper does).
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
Write comment
