Home arrow Writings arrow Was Iraq War a `Blunder' or Was It Treason?

Translate

Search

About

Pacific Free Press was launched in March 2007 by Dutch-Canadian Richard Kastelein of V.O.F. Expathos, in the Netherlands along with  Chris Cook - CFUV radio journalist and Editor in Chief of Pacific Free Press. Cook is based in , Victoria, British Columbia.

The site is a sister to Atlantic Free Press.

The mission of Pacific Free Press is simple: to dig out nuggets of truth from the slag-heap of lies, ignorance and witless diversion that has buried public discourse today. Pacific Free Press provides a new venue for disseminating hard news and insightful, fact-based analysis of the harsh realities too often ignored or distorted by the mainstream press.

 

Was Iraq War a `Blunder' or Was It Treason? Print E-mail
Written by Dave Lindorff   
Sunday, 21 January 2007
by Dave Lindorff

New Democratic House Speaker Nancy Pelosi (D-San Francisco), is calling President Bush's invasion of Iraq a "stark blunder" and says that his new scheme to send 21,500 more troops into the mess he created is just digging the hole deeper.

I wonder though.

It seems ever more likely to me that this whole mess was no blunder at all.

People are wont to attribute the whole thing to lack of intelligence on the president's part, and to hubris on the part of his key advisers. I won't argue that the president is a lightweight in the intellect department, nor will I dispute that Cheney, Rumsfeld, Wolfowitz and that whole neocon gang have demonstrably lacked the virtues of reflection and humility. But that said, I suspect that the real story of the Iraq War is that Bush and his gang never really cared whether they actually would "win" in Iraq. In fact, arguably, they didn't really want to win.

What they wanted was a war.

If the war they started had ended quickly with the overthrow of Saddam Hussein, that would have served their purposes, at least for the short term. Bush would have emerged from a short invasion and conquest a national hero, would have handily won re-election in 2004, and would have gone on to a second term as a landslide victor. But if it went badly, as it has, they figured he would still come out ahead. He would be a wartime president, and he'd make full use of that role, expansively misdefining his "commander in chief" title to imply authority over the Congress and the courts, to grab power heretofore unheard of for a president.

This, I suspect, was the grand strategy underlying the attack on Iraq.

If I'm right, there may have been method to the madness of not building up enough troops for the invasion to insure that U.S. forces could occupy a destroyed Iraq and help it rebuild, method to the madness of allowing looters free sway to destroy the country's remaining post-invasion infrastructure, method to the madness, even, of allowing remnant forces of Hussein's to gather up stockpiles of weapons and even of high-density explosives, so they could mount an effective resistance and drag out the conflict.

So many apparently stupid decisions were made by people who should clearly have been too smart to make them, from leaving hundreds of tons of high explosives unguarded to cashiering all of Iraq's army and most of the country's civil service managers, that it boggles the mind to think that these could have been just dumb ideas or incompetence. (L. Paul Bremer, for instance, who made the "dumb" decision about dismantelling the Iraqi army, prior to becoming Iraq's occupation viceroy, had headed the nation's leading risk assessment consultancy, and surely knew what all the risks were of his various decisions.)

I mean, we expect a measure of idiocy from or elected leaders and their appointees, but not wholesale idiocy!

This disaster has been so colossal, it almost had to have been orchestrated.

If that's the case, Congress should be taking a hard look at not just the latest installment of escalation, but at the whole war project, beginning with the 2002 campaign to get it going. Certainly throwing 21,500 new troops into the fire makes no sense whatever. If 140,000 of the best-equipped troops in the world can't pacify Iraq, 160,000 aren't going to be able to do it either. You don't need to be a general to figure that out. Even a senator or representative ought to be able to do it. So clearly Congress should kill this plan.

Since it's not about "winning" the war, it has to be about something else. My guess would be it's about either dragging things out until the end of 2008, so Bush can leave office without having to say he's sorry. But of course, it could also be about something even more serious: invading Iran.

We know Bush is trying mightily to provoke Iran. He has illegally attacked an Iranian consulate in Iraq (an act of war), taking six protected consular officials there captive. He is sending a second aircraft carrier battle group into the Persian Gulf, and is setting up Patriot anti-missile missile bases along Iran's western border. This buildup has all the earmarks of a pre-invasion. All that's needed now is a pretext--a real or faked attack on an American ship, perhaps, ala the Gulf of Tonkin "incident" that launched America into the Vietnam War.

The way I see it, either way the president is committing treason, because he is sending American troops off to be killed for no good reason other than for aggrandizing power he shouldn’t have, and/or simply covering his own political ass.

Treason is the number one impeachable crime under the Constitution, and we're at a point where Congress is going to have to act or go down in history as having acquiesced in the worst presidential crime in the history of the nation.
Comments (5)Add Comment
Congress' position on Iraq
written by a guest, January 21, 2007
is clearly untenable. The only way they can win an honest debate on the merits of their position is to have no debate.

None of them are talking about Ted Kennedy's sensible proposal to revoke the authorization for the use of force. They claim they're afraid they'll be accused of not supporting the troops in Iraq. And in fact they WILL be accused of refusing to support the troops in Iraq. But that accusation couldn't stick if they bring the troops home at once. Democrats could then say: "Yes, we're refusing to support the troops in Iraq any longer. We're going to bring them home and support them here."

Congress has the power. The only rational excuses they can muster for failing to use their power are cowardice and corruption. Nothing else makes any sense whatever.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
Two points
written by a guest, January 21, 2007
Not a bad effort, but the long war idea of the Busheviks and PNAC is to keep the defense industry dependent (military Keynsianism) economy going through continuous war. Thus should the Iraq War peter out, another will be needed to replace it. This is the purpose of creating a Muslim enemy to replace the communist enemy. The latter also has the advantage justifying war in resource rich countries where American corporations can benefit, and non-favored, non-American corporations can be excluded. In this sense, control of the resources is paramount.

The other point is to undermine the constitution and democracy at home. All administrations since Carter have engaged in this, but the big push has come with this Bush administration. This attack on the constitution and democracy is treasonous. But it supported by both parties, as both expect to benefit from it
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
You're Exactly Right, Dave
written by a guest, January 21, 2007
There is no doubt in my mind that you're on the right track...

... and none of this would have been possible without the attacks of 9/11 ...

... which is why they did 9/11

more treason.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
Another Gulf of Tonkin incident mighty soon
written by a guest, January 21, 2007
>:( You're right. It is obvious that there will be a Gulf-of-Tonkin incident within the next couple weeks. The American public must be alerted to this and urged to respond to it in a positive way. It must be anticipated by the vast majority of Americans. :'(
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
War = War Profits. Fog of War = Criminal Cover Ups.
written by a guest, January 22, 2007
The war had nothing to do with self defense, and everything to do with defense spending. The war had nothing to do with controlling oil and everything to do with manipulating the oil market and attaching a war risk premium to the price of oil.

The Iraq way had nothing to do with retaliation for 911 and everything to do with diverting the discussion away from the facts of 911. As cabinet level ex Bush administration officials have said, and I quote, ".. they [the neocons] blew the towers to smitherines.". Who blew WTC 7?

Lets not limit our investigations of crimes to Iraq - lets go back to 911 - that was a crime where 3000 Americans paid with their lives so those liable for the "too" big and under "leased" WTC towers would not have to pay 15 Billion dollars to destroy them (condemened several years ago for asbestos). In the WTC7, before it burned, were case documents related to the loss of 2 Trillion dollars by the DoD.

How convenient.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0

Write comment
quote
bold
italicize
underline
strike
url
image
quote
quote
smaller | bigger

busy
 
Bookmark/Tag
digg
NewsVine
Delicious
Reddit
YahooMyWeb
Furl it!
BlinkList
connotea
Fark
< Prev   Next >

 

More Author Articles

More Articles...
Getting Straight on Crooked Bankers... and their friends in government
Wednesday, 24 September 2008
Dave Lindorff
(207)
Read more
40 Years to Zero: When Government was Approachable
Sunday, 07 September 2008
Dave Lindorff
(203)
Read more
Gatemouthing Russia
Monday, 18 August 2008
Dave Lindorff
(244)
Read more
It's Easy to Reduce the Nation's (and Your Own) Fuel Bill Dramatically
Wednesday, 06 August 2008
Dave Lindorff
(306)
Read more
Omar Khadr: Protecting America the Child Soldiers
Thursday, 26 June 2008
Dave Lindorff
(595)
Read more
Pouring Gasoline on the Fires of Oil Speculation
Thursday, 12 June 2008
Dave Lindorff
(506)
Read more
Of Winners, Whiners, and Desperately Seeking a Veep
Sunday, 08 June 2008
Dave Lindorff
(400)
Read more
George Bush and the Children of the ‘War on Terror
Thursday, 22 May 2008
Dave Lindorff
(425)
Read more
War Criminal Retirement Plan: Bush's Paraguay Get-Away
Friday, 16 May 2008
Dave Lindorff
(463)
Read more
Iran and the "Oh Shit!" Moment
Saturday, 15 March 2008
Dave Lindorff
(521)
Read more
Still Broken Arrow: The Case of the Missing Nukes
Sunday, 02 March 2008
Dave Lindorff
(717)
Read more
Missteps on McCain Sex Dalliance Story
Monday, 25 February 2008
Dave Lindorff
(633)
Read more
"I have a scream" Hillary's Banshee Moment
Saturday, 05 January 2008
Dave Lindorff
(500)
Read more
Rising Tide: Red States Blue
Monday, 24 December 2007
Dave Lindorff
(606)
Read more
Minot: Loose Nukes and a Cluster of Dead Airmen
Friday, 23 November 2007
Dave Lindorff
(1120)
Read more
Impeachment Possible: Hearings in the Offing
Saturday, 10 November 2007
Dave Lindorff
(969)
Read more
At Last: House Moves on Cheney Impeachment Bill
Wednesday, 07 November 2007
Dave Lindorff
(744)
Read more
Home of the Braves
Saturday, 27 October 2007
Dave Lindorff
(771)
Read more
Iraq: Marines Are Go!
Sunday, 14 October 2007
Dave Lindorff
(801)
Read more
Kyl and Lieberman's Stealth War Authorization Attempt
Friday, 28 September 2007
Dave Lindorff
(743)
Read more
More War On: Mission Accomplished II
Saturday, 15 September 2007
Dave Lindorff
(701)
Read more
Gonzales: Saying Goodbye to the Torture Guy
Tuesday, 28 August 2007
Dave Lindorff
(771)
Read more
Re-Arming Israel: Fuelling the Fires of Perpetual War
Monday, 20 August 2007
Dave Lindorff
(946)
Read more
Terrorist Me
Thursday, 16 August 2007
Dave Lindorff
(769)
Read more
Et tu, Brute? The Man Who Would Be a King
Sunday, 05 August 2007
Dave Lindorff
(885)
Read more
Lock and Load: U.S. Martial Law a Trigger Away
Tuesday, 31 July 2007
Dave Lindorff
(1286)
Read more
Cracking the Whip, Breaking the Democrats
Thursday, 19 July 2007
Dave Lindorff
(1049)
Read more
The Dismal and the Doomed: Democrats Stand Pat
Friday, 06 July 2007
Dave Lindorff
(842)
Read more
Cheney: Vice President
Wednesday, 27 June 2007
Dave Lindorff
(950)
Read more
Reality Check for the American Press
Wednesday, 13 June 2007
Dave Lindorff
(1096)
Read more
Mumia Case Waits for Justice
Sunday, 20 May 2007
Dave Lindorff
(935)
Read more
imPeach Train Rollin'
Thursday, 03 May 2007
Dave Lindorff
(1056)
Read more
Two Bees, Nought Two Bees
Sunday, 29 April 2007
Dave Lindorff
(1038)
Read more
Cheney: Dropping the Hammer
Friday, 27 April 2007
Dave Lindorff
(1102)
Read more
Nixon 2.0: Throwin' the Bum Out
Wednesday, 18 April 2007
Dave Lindorff
(920)
Read more
Quitting the War Party(s)
Saturday, 31 March 2007
Dave Lindorff
(979)
Read more
A Hunger Growing for Impeachment
Saturday, 24 February 2007
Dave Lindorff
(879)
Read more
Truth or Consequences: Some Questions for President Bush
Thursday, 08 February 2007
Dave Lindorff
(939)
Read more
Borat Goes to Washington: Don't Experiment with the US Economy
Tuesday, 06 February 2007
Dave Lindorff
(919)
Read more
This is like Hitler's Suicide Order from the Bunker
Thursday, 01 February 2007
Dave Lindorff
(1061)
Read more
Impeachment: The Missing Word on the Stage in D.C. Last Weekend--But Not On The Street!
Tuesday, 30 January 2007
Dave Lindorff
(862)
Read more
Why We Must Have Impeachment
Friday, 26 January 2007
Dave Lindorff
(1016)
Read more
Falling Dominos and Failing Presidencies
Thursday, 25 January 2007
Dave Lindorff
(1000)
Read more
We're Takin' It To the Street January 27!
Tuesday, 23 January 2007
Dave Lindorff
(1345)
Read more
Was Iraq War a `Blunder' or Was It Treason?
Sunday, 21 January 2007
Dave Lindorff
(1105)
Read more
What Do They Think We Are, Idiots?
Friday, 19 January 2007
Dave Lindorff
(1219)
Read more
Death Watch in the Persian Gulf and Washington
Tuesday, 16 January 2007
Dave Lindorff
(1124)
Read more
Ignoring Global Warming and Our Children: Are We All Simply Mad?
Monday, 15 January 2007
Dave Lindorff
(1163)
Read more
Of Geese,Ganders and Loons
Sunday, 14 January 2007
Dave Lindorff
(1153)
Read more
No Blood For Face!
Thursday, 11 January 2007
Dave Lindorff
(1225)
Read more
There is no Justification for Delay in Stopping the War and Starting Impeachment Hearings
Wednesday, 10 January 2007
Dave Lindorff
(1159)
Read more
Democrats are Reverting to Form
Sunday, 07 January 2007
Dave Lindorff
(1160)
Read more
Crime of the Century: Are Bush & Cheney Planning Early Attack on Iran?
Saturday, 23 December 2006
Dave Lindorff
(1249)
Read more
Sell-Out Democrats Have Walked into a Bush Trap on Iraq
Wednesday, 20 December 2006
Dave Lindorff
(1236)
Read more
Sinister Cabal Takes Over Washington
Wednesday, 20 December 2006
Dave Lindorff
(1288)
Read more
Innocents Abroad: US Cracks Down on Guantanamo Detainees, Most of Whom aren't Terrorists
Saturday, 16 December 2006
Dave Lindorff
(1271)
Read more
Democratic Control of the Senate is a Double-Edged Sword
Saturday, 16 December 2006
Dave Lindorff
(1172)
Read more
Torture, Impeachment and a Vietnam Veteran's Tears
Tuesday, 12 December 2006
Dave Lindorff
(1258)
Read more
A Congress of Whores and Pipsqueaks
Friday, 08 December 2006
Dave Lindorff
(1302)
Read more
Abu-Jamal Case at Third Circuit, Prosecutor Admits He Had No "True Defense"
Wednesday, 06 December 2006
Dave Lindorff
(1233)
Read more
Fighting the Iraq War...at Home
Saturday, 02 December 2006
Dave Lindorff
(1285)
Read more
Congress Should Immediately Terminate the 2001 AUMF
Tuesday, 21 November 2006
Dave Lindorff
(1201)
Read more
Let Lieberman Go; He's an Albatross
Thursday, 16 November 2006
Dave Lindorff
(1379)
Read more
First Real Test for Democrats: The Lame Duck Session of Congress
Wednesday, 15 November 2006
Dave Lindorff
(1189)
Read more
Impeach for Change Kicks off National Campaign
Monday, 13 November 2006
Dave Lindorff
(1160)
Read more
National Impeachment Movement this Saturday in Philadelphia!
Friday, 10 November 2006
Dave Lindorff
(1382)
Read more
What Vote-Theft Conspiracy?
Thursday, 09 November 2006
Dave Lindorff
(1282)
Read more
Election Postmortem: What's Next?
Wednesday, 08 November 2006
Dave Lindorff
(1381)
Read more
It's Election Eve, Do You Know Where Your Country Is?
Monday, 06 November 2006
Dave Lindorff
(1192)
Read more
Philly Inquirer: Making Biased News out of Mole Hills
Saturday, 04 November 2006
Dave Lindorff
(1394)
Read more
Kerry and Bush: The Joke's on Us
Thursday, 02 November 2006
Dave Lindorff
(1887)
Read more
Why Nancy Pelosi Has it Wrong on Impeachment
Wednesday, 25 October 2006
Dave Lindorff
(1577)
Read more
Let's March in January! An Impeachment Call to Action
Tuesday, 24 October 2006
Dave Lindorff
(1537)
Read more
Time for Truth and Consequences
Monday, 23 October 2006
Dave Lindorff
(1280)
Read more
Bush's Middle East Strategy, and Presidency, Lie in Ruins as Republicans Scurry Away
Wednesday, 18 October 2006
Dave Lindorff
(1315)
Read more
U.S. Military Has Killed Up to 238,000 Iraqi Civilians
Wednesday, 11 October 2006
Dave Lindorff
(1791)
Read more
BREAKING NEWS: Eisenhower Carrier Group Sails for Iran Theater
Tuesday, 10 October 2006
Dave Lindorff
(4630)
Read more
Chris Floyd

 

Amazon.com

Paul William Roberts



Amazon.com

Norman Solomon

Amazon.com

Heather Wokusch


Amazon.com

Andrew Bard Schmookler


Amazon.com

Shahid Alam


Amazon.com

Ramzy Baroud

Amazon.com
 

James Kunstler 

 

Amazon.com 

Joel Hirschhorn
 
Amazon.com

Jonathan Cook


Amazon.com

Jason Leopold



Amazon.com

Dennis Jett

Amazon.com


Dr. Walter Brasch



Amazon.com



Dave Lindorff

 

Amazon.com 

 

William A. Cook 



Amazon.com 


Rod Amis

 

Amazon.com 

 

Mickey Z

 

Amazon.com 


Mark
Crispin Miller


 

Amazon.com


Expathos
               No account yet?


Page was generated in 2.039797 seconds