With Respect to Journalists Covering 'Indigenous Issues'
by Shelley Bluejay Pierce
Dear Mr. Taylor; I was compelled today, to respond to your media coverage and the public commentary on the Native issues surrounding the disputes currently active in Ontario.
As a journalist covering Indigenous issues worldwide, I see similar situations and conflicts between Native and non-Native peoples in every country across the globe. However, I have been an active media supporter to the people of Six Nations since day one of their occupation in Caledonia. My support has continued to expand so that issues at Tyendinaga, Attawapiskat and other reserves are also part of my normal coverage.
As a journalist covering Indigenous issues worldwide, I see similar situations and conflicts between Native and non-Native peoples in every country across the globe. However, I have been an active media supporter to the people of Six Nations since day one of their occupation in Caledonia. My support has continued to expand so that issues at Tyendinaga, Attawapiskat and other reserves are also part of my normal coverage.
During the two years that I have been involved with the Six
Nations people in their struggles, I have seen consistent media
coverage that shines the spotlight only on the Non-native perspective.
What becomes glaringly obvious, is that your journalists and other
members of the
Canadian media behave in an all too well known behavior when it comes to covering Indigenous issues.
In order to truly understand another’s' point of view, one must dare to step over into their realm. This is not accomplished in a hastily made 30-second interview by phone. This connection to understanding alternative perspectives is not accomplished by shoving a microphone in front of a strangers' face and asking for an instant response.
Nowhere in the journalism field is this more important than in dealing with cultures different from that of the "mainstream" society. In this case, I refer to the Six Nations members versus the predominant Colonial Canadian citizenry. When I was first working alongside members of Six Nations, I attempted to contact members of the Canadian media in hopes to educate them and introduce them properly to those specific leaders inside Six Nations who were authorized to speak on behalf of their People. In our way of doing things, this is a polite and proper courtesy that is extended between outsiders who are attempting to visit with our leadership. None of the Canadian or U.S. media responded to many open invitations to partake in this opportunity to meet, understand and discuss these issues with Six Nation leadership.
The ongoing press about these "uprisings" only substantiates what we, as a People, have always known. The dominant society continues to dwell within their "colonial, civilized vs. savages" mentality and they are perpetuating the myths and stereotypes about WHO we are based on history books written by non-Native people. This is not reality Mr. Taylor.
What mainstream media has so miserably failed at, is learning what the true motivations are behind the culture of a Nation. The land is not something to be "owned." The land is cared for, nurtured and protected at all cost because it is the very connection we have to all the history, culture and ancestors who have walked this land before us. What we have always known is that we cannot abuse the very land that sustains us. The "colonial" attitudes are the very behaviors moving us all, globally, towards mass extinction. When there is no safe water to drink, no clean air or food available, it will be too late to decide that we cannot survive by eating money.
Had ANY of the mainstream media acted upon invitations to actually meet the leaders of Six Nations and have honest dialogue? We may not be at the current state of affairs that we see now.
As to the article in your paper covering the events at Tyendinaga, I would like to respond to a few inaccurate statements:
Canadian media behave in an all too well known behavior when it comes to covering Indigenous issues.
In order to truly understand another’s' point of view, one must dare to step over into their realm. This is not accomplished in a hastily made 30-second interview by phone. This connection to understanding alternative perspectives is not accomplished by shoving a microphone in front of a strangers' face and asking for an instant response.
Nowhere in the journalism field is this more important than in dealing with cultures different from that of the "mainstream" society. In this case, I refer to the Six Nations members versus the predominant Colonial Canadian citizenry. When I was first working alongside members of Six Nations, I attempted to contact members of the Canadian media in hopes to educate them and introduce them properly to those specific leaders inside Six Nations who were authorized to speak on behalf of their People. In our way of doing things, this is a polite and proper courtesy that is extended between outsiders who are attempting to visit with our leadership. None of the Canadian or U.S. media responded to many open invitations to partake in this opportunity to meet, understand and discuss these issues with Six Nation leadership.
The ongoing press about these "uprisings" only substantiates what we, as a People, have always known. The dominant society continues to dwell within their "colonial, civilized vs. savages" mentality and they are perpetuating the myths and stereotypes about WHO we are based on history books written by non-Native people. This is not reality Mr. Taylor.
What mainstream media has so miserably failed at, is learning what the true motivations are behind the culture of a Nation. The land is not something to be "owned." The land is cared for, nurtured and protected at all cost because it is the very connection we have to all the history, culture and ancestors who have walked this land before us. What we have always known is that we cannot abuse the very land that sustains us. The "colonial" attitudes are the very behaviors moving us all, globally, towards mass extinction. When there is no safe water to drink, no clean air or food available, it will be too late to decide that we cannot survive by eating money.
Had ANY of the mainstream media acted upon invitations to actually meet the leaders of Six Nations and have honest dialogue? We may not be at the current state of affairs that we see now.
As to the article in your paper covering the events at Tyendinaga, I would like to respond to a few inaccurate statements:
- "two officers were assaulted near Deseronto, Ont."
The journalists failed to report on the assaults upon the Native
people that led up to the confrontations with these officers. I spoke
to those members who were present at the events leading up to this
confrontation and they assured me, that no one in the media asked for
THEIR side of the story.
As to some of the public comments section, which I realize, you have no control over:
The dominant society continues to dwell within their "colonial, civilized vs. savages" mentality and they are perpetuating the myths and stereotypes about WHO we are based on history books written by non-Native people. The land is cared for, nurtured and protected at all cost because it is the very connection we have to all the history, culture and ancestors who have walked this land before us. What we have always known is that we cannot abuse the very land that sustains us. The "colonial" attitudes are the very behaviors moving us all, globally, toward mass extinction. When there is no safe water to drink, no clean air or food available, it will be too late to decide that we cannot survive by eating money.
Sincerely,
Shelley Bluejay Pierce
International Journalist- Indigenous Issues
This e-mail address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it
Bozeman, Montana, USA
- "there were reports that police saw one of the demonstrators pointing a long gun at them."
- "Sgt. Rae said heavy police presence was expected in the area through the night."
As to some of the public comments section, which I realize, you have no control over:
- "Illegal protests should not be tolerated, if a non-native pointed a gun at a police officer the SWAT team would be there in no time at all- it's time to enforce the law in Native communities in the same way that it is for the rest of us."
- "Integrate the Natives as regular Citizens of Canada now!"
The dominant society continues to dwell within their "colonial, civilized vs. savages" mentality and they are perpetuating the myths and stereotypes about WHO we are based on history books written by non-Native people. The land is cared for, nurtured and protected at all cost because it is the very connection we have to all the history, culture and ancestors who have walked this land before us. What we have always known is that we cannot abuse the very land that sustains us. The "colonial" attitudes are the very behaviors moving us all, globally, toward mass extinction. When there is no safe water to drink, no clean air or food available, it will be too late to decide that we cannot survive by eating money.
Sincerely,
Shelley Bluejay Pierce
International Journalist- Indigenous Issues
This e-mail address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it
Bozeman, Montana, USA
Set as favorite
Bookmark
Email This
Comments (0)

Write comment

Mister Wong
Digg
Del.icio.us
Slashdot
Furl
Yahoo
Technorati
Newsvine
Googlize this
Blinklist
Facebook
Wikio