Home arrow Writings arrow Torture State: The Returns of Tyranny

Translate

Search

About

Pacific Free Press was launched in March 2007 by Dutch-Canadian Richard Kastelein of V.O.F. Expathos, in the Netherlands along with  Chris Cook - CFUV radio journalist and Editor in Chief of Pacific Free Press. Cook is based in , Victoria, British Columbia.

The site is a sister to Atlantic Free Press and Brick Ogden an American Expatriate in Amsterdam has been a key supporter of this project.

The mission of Pacific Free Press is simple: to dig out nuggets of truth from the slag-heap of lies, ignorance and witless diversion that has buried public discourse today. Pacific Free Press provides a new venue for disseminating hard news and insightful, fact-based analysis of the harsh realities too often ignored or distorted by the mainstream press.

 

Torture State: The Returns of Tyranny Print E-mail
Written by Chris Floyd   
Saturday, 18 August 2007
Monsters Among Us: Living in a Torture State        
by Chris Floyd     
Scott Horton has just put up an important, hard-hitting post: Bush and the Art of Breaking Human Beings. Horton amplifies the harrowing details of the Bush Administration's Stalinist persecution of U.S. citizen Jose Padilla, reported yesterday by the Christian Science Monitor's Warren Richey.
 
You should read the whole piece right away, but this passage that Horton quotes from Jack Balkin puts the case in its larger -- and most chilling -- perspective. Says Balkin:

It’s important to remember that the Bush Administration did everything it could to deny Padilla even the basic right of habeas corpus. It argued that courts had no power to second guess the President’s determination that Padilla was an enemy of the United States and could be held in solitary confinement indefinitely. It argued that no one had the right to contact Padilla and that no one had the right to know what the government was doing to him. It argued that courts should defer to the President’s views about who was dangerous and who was not—that once the President declared a person an enemy, that person had all the process that was due them and courts should respect that determination.

It argued, in short, that the President always knows best. If the President had his way, the government, on the basis of information that never had to be tested before any neutral magistrate, could pluck any citizen off the streets, throw them in a military prison, and proceed to drive them insane.

Those are the powers that the Bush Administration sought. I will not mince words: They are the powers of a dictator in an authoritarian regime. They are the powers of the old Soviet Union, of the military junta in Argentina during the time of the disappeared.


We are all Jose Padilla now.


 
Well, John the Baptist after torturing a thief
Looks up at his hero the Commander-in-Chief
Saying, "Tell me great hero, but please make it brief
Is there a hole for me to get sick in?"

The Commander-in-Chief answers him while chasing a fly
Saying, "Death to all those who would whimper and cry"
And dropping a bar bell he points to the sky
Saying, "The sun's not yellow it's chicken"

                                                    - Bob Dylan

"Beat, beat, beat, and beat again."
                                                           - Joseph Stalin 
 

I've been writing about Bush's seizure of arbitrary powers since November 2001, when I first took note of the universal license to kill that he had granted himself:

The Washington Post reports this week that George W. Bush has signed an executive order giving himself the right to issue death warrants for any individual he deems a terrorist or terrorist supporter. These people will be killed in secret by the CIA, without any pretense of due process, without defense or appeal...

Bush's license to kill leaves the meaning of "terrorist" and "terrorist supporter" deliberately vague. The definition is entirely up to the president: there is no legislative oversight, no judicial review, no public scrutiny. If he wants you dead, he can have you killed. It's as simple as that.

This official acceptance of the principle of extra-judicial murder degrades the American government to the level of moral savagery. It is the same "principle" underlying all terrorist activity: a threat to a group's interests is arbitrarily defined by its leaders, who then act arbitrarily, lawlessly, to eliminate the threat...It is the principle of evildoers, men of blood, murderers and beasts. And it is now a guiding light of the "civilized" world.


All of this was enshrined in "law" by Congress last fall, when it passed the "Military Commissions Act" -- an "enabling act" for tyranny that the new, Democratic-led Congress has not bothered to repeal. As I noted at the time:


It was a dark hour indeed last Thursday when the United States Senate voted to end the constitutional republic and transform the country into a "Leader-State," giving the president and his agents the power to capture, torture and imprison forever anyone - American citizens included - whom they arbitrarily decide is an "enemy combatant." This also includes those who merely give "terrorism" some kind of "support," defined so vaguely that many experts say it could encompass legal advice, innocent gifts to charities or even political opposition to US government policy within its draconian strictures.

All of this is bad enough - a sickening and cowardly surrender of liberty not seen in a major Western democracy since the Enabling Act passed by the German Reichstag in March 1933. But it is by no means the full extent of our degradation. In reality, the darkness is deeper, and more foul, than most people imagine. For in addition to the dictatorial powers of seizure and torment given by Congress on Thursday to George W. Bush - powers he had already seized and exercised for five years anyway, even without this fig leaf of sham legality - there is a far more sinister imperial right that Bush has claimed - and used - openly, without any demur or debate from Congress at all: ordering the "extrajudicial killing" of anyone on earth that he and his deputies decide - arbitrarily, without charges, court hearing, formal evidence, or appeal - is an "enemy combatant."

That's right; from the earliest days of the Terror War - September 17, 2001, to be exact - Bush has claimed the peremptory power of life and death over the entire world. If he says you're an enemy of America, you are. If he wants to imprison you and torture you, he can. And if he decides you should die, he'll kill you. This is not hyperbole, liberal paranoia, or "conspiracy theory": it's simply a fact, reported by the mainstream media, attested by senior administration figures, recorded in official government documents - and boasted about by the president himself, in front of Congress and a national television audience.

And although the Republic-snuffing act just passed by Congress does not directly address Bush's royal prerogative of murder, it nonetheless strengthens it and enshrines it in law. For the measure sets forth clearly that the designation of an "enemy combatant" is left solely to the executive branch; neither Congress nor the courts have any say in the matter. When this new law is coupled with the existing "Executive Orders" authorizing "lethal force" against arbitrarily designated "enemy combatants," it becomes, quite literally, a license to kill - with the seal of Congressional approval....

The first officially confirmed use of this power was the killing of an American citizen, along with several foreign nationals, by a CIA drone missile in Yemen on November 3, 2002. A similar strike occurred on December 4, 2005, when a CIA missile destroyed a house and purportedly killed Abu Hamza Rabia, a suspected al-Qaeda figure. But the only bodies found at the site were those of two children, the houseowner's son and nephew, Reuters reports. The grieving father denied any connection to terrorism. An earlier CIA strike on another house missed Rabia but killed his wife and children, Pakistani officials reported.

However, there is simply no way of knowing at this point how many people have been killed by American agents operating outside all judicial process. Most of the assassinations are carried out in secret: quietly, professionally. As a Pentagon document uncovered by the New Yorker in December 2002 revealed, the death squads must be "small and agile," and "able to operate clandestinely, using a full range of official and non-official cover arrangements to ... enter countries surreptitiously."

What's more, there are strong indications that the Bush administration has outsourced some of the contracts to outside operators. In the original Post story about the assassinations - in those first heady weeks after 9/11, when administration officials were much more open about "going to the dark side," as Cheney boasted on national television - Bush insiders told the paper that "it is also possible that the instrument of targeted killings will be foreign agents, the CIA's term for nonemployees who act on its behalf."


In that article, I quoted from an earlier piece about Bush's brazen championing of this arbitrary power to kill, in "one of the most revolting scenes in recent American history: Bush's state of the Union address in January 2003, delivered live to the nation during the final warmongering frenzy before the rape of Iraq":


Trumpeting his successes in the Terror War, Bush claimed that "more than 3,000 suspected terrorists" had been arrested worldwide - "and many others have met a different fate." His face then took on the characteristic leer, the strange, sickly half-smile it acquires whenever he speaks of killing people: "Let's put it this way. They are no longer a problem."

In other words, the suspects - and even Bush acknowledged they were only suspects - had been murdered. Lynched. Killed by agents operating unsupervised in that shadow world where intelligence, terrorism, politics, finance and organized crime meld together in one amorphous, impenetrable mass. Killed on the word of a dubious informer, perhaps: a tortured captive willing to say anything to end his torment, a business rival, a personal foe, a bureaucrat looking to impress his superiors, a paid snitch in need of cash, a zealous crank pursuing ethnic, tribal or religious hatreds - or any other purveyor of the garbage data that is coin of the realm in the shadow world.

Bush proudly held up this hideous system as an example of what he called "the meaning of American justice." And the assembled legislators ... applauded. Oh, how they applauded! They roared with glee at the leering little man's bloodthirsty, B-movie machismo. They shared his sneering contempt for law - our only shield, however imperfect, against the blind, brute, ignorant, ape-like force of raw power. Not a single voice among them was raised in protest against this tyrannical machtpolitik: not that night, not the next day, not ever.


This is the United States today, this is what we've come to. Is there a hole big enough for us all to get sick in?

UPDATE: Scott Horton pursues the torture theme further, with this fascinating look back at the unlikely figure who played a pivotal role in eliminating legalized torture in the English-speaking world for almost 300 years: John Donne. Here's an excerpt:


Over a series of centuries, the genius of the English law had been steadily to restrict and limit the use of torture, until at this point, under King James, it was controlled by the king’s judges and limited in practice through a series of special writs. Which is to say, legally it was far more constrained than it is today under an Executive Order issued by King James’s understudy in allegedly Divine Right governance, George W. Bush.

[In his Easter Sunday sermon of 1625], Donne delivered a direct blow against this system, the use to which it was put, and the suffering it caused. He makes no equivocations. And in the end he delivers his blows against even the king’s judges who administer the system. No one viewed Donne as a “political figure.” Indeed, owing to his Catholic background and sympathies, he eschewed court politics. Nor in the end was there anything “political” about the question of torture—it was an issue of ethics and of faith...

Donne points to the ultimate irony of the use of torture, not to punish the guilty, but as a tool to extract information—when it is well established that doesn’t serve that end. He notes the immorality of this practice. John Donne was the most important clerical voice in England in his day. His opinion carried weight. Only three years after this sermon, following the assassination of the Duke of Buckingham, the lawyers and judges of England assembled in the Inns of Court in London to consider a special question put to them by the king. Was the practice of torture to be permitted by the common law?

And the judges met, deliberated and declared “upon their sacred honour, and the honour of England” that the answer was “no.” That marked the end of legalized torture in the English-speaking world… until the arrival of George W. Bush.
  
solitude is a torment which is not threatened in Hell itself.”  
                                          - John Donne
 
 
Comments (0)Add Comment

Write comment
quote
bold
italicize
underline
strike
url
image
quote
quote
smaller | bigger

busy
 
Bookmark/Tag
digg
NewsVine
Delicious
Reddit
YahooMyWeb
Furl it!
BlinkList
connotea
Fark
< Prev   Next >

More Author Articles

More Articles...
The Nangarhar Massacre
Thursday, 17 July 2008
Chris Floyd
(52)
Read more
Somalia's American-Made Road to Perdition
Thursday, 10 July 2008
Chris Floyd
(116)
Read more
Again Down History's Dark Roads
Thursday, 03 July 2008
Chris Floyd
(162)
Read more
A History of Brief Hope and Hype
Sunday, 15 June 2008
Chris Floyd
(318)
Read more
Shades of Significance: Breaking the Pale Monopoly
Saturday, 07 June 2008
Chris Floyd
(233)
Read more
The Self-Righteous Hit on Hillary
Thursday, 29 May 2008
Chris Floyd
(370)
Read more
The Shared Fate of a "Special Relationship"
Thursday, 22 May 2008
Chris Floyd
(229)
Read more
Snapshots of a World on the Edge
Sunday, 18 May 2008
Chris Floyd
(337)
Read more
Fomenting War in Lebanon
Thursday, 15 May 2008
Chris Floyd
(206)
Read more
Rules of Engagement: Shoot, Kill, Lie, Repeat
Saturday, 10 May 2008
Chris Floyd
(271)
Read more
Fallujah Comes to Sadr City
Friday, 09 May 2008
Chris Floyd
(402)
Read more
Feeding Moloch
Friday, 02 May 2008
Chris Floyd
(368)
Read more
Protection with Extreme Prejudice
Thursday, 01 May 2008
Chris Floyd
(321)
Read more
Glad Embrace: America and the Dictator
Saturday, 26 April 2008
Chris Floyd
(349)
Read more
SEX and CARS and SEX and GUNS and Somalia
Wednesday, 23 April 2008
Chris Floyd
(557)
Read more
Team Torture: Accounting for Bush and Co.
Sunday, 20 April 2008
Chris Floyd
(417)
Read more
In Defense of John Yoo
Thursday, 10 April 2008
Chris Floyd
(400)
Read more
A Radical Unremembered
Saturday, 05 April 2008
Chris Floyd
(364)
Read more
Ignorance Puts Iraq on the Cross
Thursday, 27 March 2008
Chris Floyd
(373)
Read more
Iran in the Shadow of War
Wednesday, 19 March 2008
Chris Floyd
(419)
Read more
More than Sex: Spitzer Meets the Real Governor
Thursday, 13 March 2008
Chris Floyd
(409)
Read more
Obama and the Delicate Balance of Reality
Saturday, 01 March 2008
Chris Floyd
(388)
Read more
Death and Chaos No Problem for Profit-Seekers in Iraq
Thursday, 28 February 2008
Chris Floyd
(383)
Read more
Empire and Burlesque
Sunday, 24 February 2008
Chris Floyd
(523)
Read more
Praise Judge Scalia, Who Gives Us Hope in This Dark Hour
Sunday, 17 February 2008
Chris Floyd
(405)
Read more
Return of the Empire Burlesque
Saturday, 16 February 2008
Chris Floyd
(413)
Read more
An Elite Exposed in an Exit Speech
Sunday, 10 February 2008
Chris Floyd
(462)
Read more
Criminal Intent: America's Air War over Baghdad
Thursday, 07 February 2008
Chris Floyd
(459)
Read more
Electing The Great American President
Saturday, 02 February 2008
Chris Floyd
(509)
Read more
Why We (Canadians) Fight in Afghanistan
Saturday, 26 January 2008
Chris Floyd
(488)
Read more
Crime Without Arrest
Tuesday, 22 January 2008
Chris Floyd
(406)
Read more
Front Lines of a War Crime
Sunday, 20 January 2008
Chris Floyd
(450)
Read more
Number Crunching the Death Count
Monday, 14 January 2008
Chris Floyd
(509)
Read more
Warrior on Drugs: War without Tears
Saturday, 12 January 2008
Chris Floyd
(736)
Read more
Shadows: Proliferation, Corruption and the Way of the World
Thursday, 10 January 2008
Chris Floyd
(676)
Read more
Haditha: No Justice for Iraq Atrocity
Sunday, 06 January 2008
Chris Floyd
(494)
Read more
War Parties United
Thursday, 03 January 2008
Chris Floyd
(505)
Read more
Not Alright, Jack: A State of the Union
Sunday, 30 December 2007
Chris Floyd
(445)
Read more
Al Gore and the Bali Ballyhoo
Saturday, 29 December 2007
Chris Floyd
(448)
Read more
Clarity and Truth Resurrected
Sunday, 23 December 2007
Chris Floyd
(352)
Read more
The Democrat's Progress: No Progress
Sunday, 16 December 2007
Chris Floyd
(485)
Read more
Bailing out Again the Billionaires
Friday, 14 December 2007
Chris Floyd
(454)
Read more
An Expert Dissection of the NIE Report
Wednesday, 05 December 2007
Chris Floyd
(580)
Read more
The (other) War Party
Monday, 03 December 2007
Chris Floyd
(773)
Read more
Cluing in on the Racist Effete
Wednesday, 28 November 2007
Chris Floyd
(855)
Read more
Passing: Howard the Schmuck
Sunday, 25 November 2007
Chris Floyd
(902)
Read more
Martin Amis and the Gentile Racists
Thursday, 22 November 2007
Chris Floyd
(913)
Read more
Defending the Constitutional Right to Torture
Monday, 12 November 2007
Chris Floyd
(688)
Read more
A Cowed Nation's Wilful Surrender
Wednesday, 07 November 2007
Chris Floyd
(789)
Read more
Just Shoot Me
Saturday, 03 November 2007
Chris Floyd
(733)
Read more
NRA Gun Cult Goes South of the Border
Wednesday, 31 October 2007
Chris Floyd
(1067)
Read more
Rebuking the Truth, Mocking the Dead
Saturday, 20 October 2007
Chris Floyd
(682)
Read more
Torture World: Laying Back and Enjoying It
Sunday, 14 October 2007
Chris Floyd
(579)
Read more
Plan Opium: Afghanistan's Coming Fumigare
Thursday, 11 October 2007
Chris Floyd
(791)
Read more
Marching Into Nightmare with 'King David' General Petraeus
Monday, 08 October 2007
Chris Floyd
(723)
Read more
Back From the Hack, and Once More Into the Breach
Thursday, 04 October 2007
Chris Floyd
(834)
Read more
Iraq: Plumbing the Depths
Thursday, 27 September 2007
Chris Floyd
(679)
Read more
The Cash of Civilizations: Bombs and Baksheesh
Wednesday, 19 September 2007
Chris Floyd
(683)
Read more
Britain: Clinging to the War Wagon
Thursday, 13 September 2007
Chris Floyd
(788)
Read more
9/11: Swamp Gas
Wednesday, 12 September 2007
Chris Floyd
(819)
Read more
First Tucker Came for the Fags
Saturday, 01 September 2007
Chris Floyd
(703)
Read more
Catch-22 Redux
Wednesday, 22 August 2007
Chris Floyd
(879)
Read more
Bushists Through the Looking-Glass on Iran
Monday, 20 August 2007
Chris Floyd
(933)
Read more
Torture State: The Returns of Tyranny
Saturday, 18 August 2007
Chris Floyd
(732)
Read more
Silber: A Final Word on Iran
Friday, 17 August 2007
Chris Floyd
(842)
Read more
Rove Goes But the Malevolent Machine Rolls On
Wednesday, 15 August 2007
Chris Floyd
(805)
Read more
Panic Attack: Rove Packs Bags in Big-Time Bushist Bug-Out
Monday, 13 August 2007
Chris Floyd
(839)
Read more
FEMA Writ Large: Masters of Disaster
Thursday, 09 August 2007
Chris Floyd
(980)
Read more
Further On Bush's Anti-Dissent Order
Sunday, 05 August 2007
Chris Floyd
(999)
Read more
Money Power and the Minneapolis Bridge
Sunday, 05 August 2007
Chris Floyd
(989)
Read more
More on Bush's Anti-Dissent Order
Tuesday, 31 July 2007
Chris Floyd
(1052)
Read more
Failed Surge: Death from Above
Thursday, 26 July 2007
Chris Floyd
(754)
Read more
Pervert's Parade: Executive Privilege
Saturday, 21 July 2007
Chris Floyd
(681)
Read more
Bad, Bad, Vlad
Wednesday, 18 July 2007
Chris Floyd
(946)
Read more
Iran: Senate Issues Unanimous War Cheque
Friday, 13 July 2007
Chris Floyd
(1642)
Read more
Hanging on to the Holocene Days
Monday, 09 July 2007
Chris Floyd
(790)
Read more
Bone Dance: A Late Epiphany at the New York Times
Monday, 09 July 2007
Chris Floyd
(851)
Read more
Iran: Another Turn of the Propaganda Screw
Monday, 02 July 2007
Chris Floyd
(2320)
Read more
Liberate with Extreme Prejudice
Sunday, 01 July 2007
Chris Floyd
(1099)
Read more
Law Gone South
Wednesday, 27 June 2007
Chris Floyd
(1372)
Read more
Tragic Legacy
Monday, 25 June 2007
Chris Floyd
(1001)
Read more
Pawns
Saturday, 16 June 2007
Chris Floyd
(883)
Read more
Somalia: "Kill Them All"
Wednesday, 13 June 2007
Chris Floyd
(741)
Read more
Sami al-Haj: The Last King of Cuba
Monday, 11 June 2007
Chris Floyd
(1015)
Read more
Bandar Bush and the Bandergate Revelations
Sunday, 10 June 2007
Chris Floyd
(1073)
Read more
Lost Kitt Hitchens
Saturday, 02 June 2007
Chris Floyd
(1051)
Read more
The Lie of Lebanon Refugee Crisis
Sunday, 27 May 2007
Chris Floyd
(929)
Read more
Iran: Surfin' the Surge
Thursday, 24 May 2007
Chris Floyd
(890)
Read more
Riding the Regime Change Trail
Monday, 21 May 2007
Chris Floyd
(913)
Read more
A Farewell to Falwell
Thursday, 17 May 2007
Chris Floyd
(812)
Read more
Britons Pay for Bush Crimes
Sunday, 13 May 2007
Chris Floyd
(972)
Read more
Hacking Dissent
Tuesday, 08 May 2007
Chris Floyd
(1100)
Read more
Shock and Yawn
Wednesday, 02 May 2007
Chris Floyd
(965)
Read more
Somalia: Getting the Real Story
Friday, 27 April 2007
Chris Floyd
(1357)
Read more
Somalia: Filling the Streets with the Dead
Monday, 23 April 2007
Chris Floyd
(1378)
Read more
Walling In Iraqis
Saturday, 21 April 2007
Chris Floyd
(947)
Read more
No Refuge
Sunday, 15 April 2007
Chris Floyd
(1213)
Read more
Hello. Goodbye. Kurt Vonnegut Off to Tralfamador
Thursday, 12 April 2007
Chris Floyd
(1464)
Read more
Somalia Terror War Spreading
Monday, 09 April 2007
Chris Floyd
(1056)
Read more
All the Perfume of Arabia...
Friday, 06 April 2007
Chris Floyd
(1140)
Read more
Iraq: Again Claiming the Prize
Thursday, 05 April 2007
Chris Floyd
(1051)
Read more
Slavery Now!
Wednesday, 04 April 2007
Chris Floyd
(1071)
Read more
Black Hawk Up: Back to Club Mog
Sunday, 01 April 2007
Chris Floyd
(1159)
Read more
The 'Post Human' Society
Saturday, 31 March 2007
Chris Floyd
(976)
Read more
That 'Other' Regime Change
Monday, 26 March 2007
Chris Floyd
(1005)
Read more
Rendered Unto Caesar
Friday, 23 March 2007
Chris Floyd
(987)
Read more
Oprah's Mysterious Hole on America
Friday, 09 March 2007
Chris Floyd
(1150)
Read more
A Tip o' the Hat
Friday, 09 March 2007
Chris Floyd
(1168)
Read more
A Free Press
Monday, 05 March 2007
Chris Floyd
(1567)
Read more
Operation Enduring Idiocy
Saturday, 03 March 2007
Chris Floyd
(1293)
Read more
Bush Faction Arming Al Qaeda
Monday, 26 February 2007
Chris Floyd
(948)
Read more
Riverbend: The Rape of Sabrine al-Janabi
Thursday, 22 February 2007
Chris Floyd
(1187)
Read more
Dirty War, Dirty Warriors
Sunday, 18 February 2007
Chris Floyd
(912)
Read more
Ersatz Apocalypto: Slaughter and Spin in